Feedback & Assessment · For teachers

How can you spot feedback that sounds precise but is wrong?

The short answer

Check each comment against three things: the response the student actually submitted, the correct subject content and the task criteria. Find the exact evidence before accepting a claimed weakness. Rework any proposed correction yourself, and reject extra requirements that the task never set. Specific wording alone does not make feedback accurate.

Four things to remember

  1. A named sentence or criterion is a claim you can check, not proof the comment is right.
  2. Check an alleged omission against the complete response before asking students to add more.
  3. Recalculate or verify a proposed correction independently.
  4. Separate a required improvement from an optional extension, and hold uncertain feedback for clarification.

Why can a specific comment still be wrong?

Consider a comment that names a paragraph, quotes a phrase and gives a precise instruction. Each feature makes the advice easier to locate, but none establishes that the diagnosis is correct. The phrase may already be explained. The suggested correction may introduce an error. The instruction may belong to a different task. Read the comment as a set of claims that need evidence.

The Australian Framework for Generative AI in Schools identifies the possibility of errors in generated content and places responsibility for decisions with teachers and school leaders. That is a reason to check a draft, not a claim about how often a particular product makes mistakes. These checks also apply to a comment copied from a bank or written by another person.

All responses, task instructions and faulty comments below are invented teaching examples. They are not real student work, official marking exemplars or recorded outputs from any AI tool. Use them to practise checking the relationship between a comment and its evidence, rather than to estimate a tool’s accuracy.

How do you check a claim that evidence is missing?

Start with this invented passage: ‘”Not my problem,” Mei says, pulling a second chair beside her.’ The practice task asks students to explain how speech and action present Mei. An invented response reads: ‘”Not my problem” sounds dismissive, but moving a chair beside her suggests she is making space for someone.’

Now inspect this faulty comment: ‘You describe Mei’s action without quoting her dialogue. Add a quotation before explaining the contrast.’ The instruction sounds actionable, but its first claim is false: the response already quotes the dialogue and connects it to the action. Asking for another quotation would not repair the alleged gap.

A defensible replacement is: ‘You have quoted Mei’s dialogue and explained its contrast with her action.’ There is no need to invent a new weakness to replace the mistaken one. If another part of the response needs development, identify that separately and show where. Check the complete submitted response before deciding evidence is missing; a cropped page or an incomplete text extract can change what you see.

How do you test a proposed correction?

Use an invented maths task: ‘Calculate 5/8 + 1/8 and give the result in simplest form.’ The response is ‘5/8 + 1/8 = 6/8 = 3/4.’ A faulty comment says: ‘You correctly added the numerators, but you must also add the denominators. Change 6/8 to 6/16, which simplifies to 3/8.’

Recalculate without following the comment’s method. Five eighths plus one eighth makes six eighths, so the denominator stays eight. Dividing the numerator and denominator of 6/8 by two gives 3/4. The student’s result is correct; the suggested change would halve it. A second check is that 3/8 is smaller than the starting 5/8, although a positive 1/8 was added.

Replace the faulty instruction with an accurate observation: ‘You kept the common denominator and simplified 6/8 correctly to 3/4.’ The useful lesson is the checking process, not a warning against a particular tool. For an unfamiliar subject claim, use the relevant source material or ask a colleague with that expertise before sending a correction. Asking the same tool to repeat its answer is not an independent calculation or source check.

How do you catch a requirement the task never set?

Here is a separate invented practice task: ‘Use the paragraph to explain one reason the match was cancelled.’ Its two criteria are to identify a relevant reason and explain why it led to cancellation. The supplied paragraph says that overnight rain flooded the pitch and officials called off the match because the surface was unsafe.

The response says: ‘Rain flooded the pitch, leaving an unsafe surface, so officials cancelled the match.’ A faulty comment reads: ‘To meet the second criterion, you must provide three separate causes.’ Compare that requirement with the actual task: it asks for one reason with an explanation, not three causes. Counting extra causes would assess a different demand.

A suitable observation is: ‘You identify the flooding and explain that the unsafe surface led to cancellation.’ An extension could explore another consequence, but label it as an extension rather than a condition of meeting this task. Before changing a judgement, also check any separate instructions or agreed marking guidance that apply to the real assessment. The invented criteria here cannot settle a different task.

What should you record before feedback goes out?

Keep the response, the task and the draft comment beside one another. Underline the comment’s claim, locate the evidence that supports or contradicts it, and decide whether to keep, correct or hold the comment. The review sheet below gives you a compact record. Record the reason for your decision, not just a tick saying ‘checked’.

When a comment combines a valid observation with an invalid instruction, separate them. In the fraction example, adding the numerators is correct; changing the denominator is not. Rewrite the complete comment so the student receives one coherent message. Leaving a wrong instruction in place and adding a correction later in the paragraph creates avoidable confusion.

A feedback comment bank can help you phrase the replacement, but it cannot supply the missing judgement. Read the adapted wording against this response and criterion.

Once the comment is sound, plan time for the student to use it; the ten-minute returned-feedback lesson includes a fresh check that goes beyond copying a correction.

What if you still cannot resolve the comment?

Hold the disputed advice until you can clarify the source, task requirement or interpretation. If the original work and its extracted text differ, resolve that mismatch before deciding what the student has done. If two readings are plausible, identify the evidence for each instead of presenting your preferred wording as the only possible answer.

If incorrect advice has already reached a student, give them a clear correction that names what was wrong and what they should now use. Follow your school’s process for any affected mark. For recurring issues, keep a permitted, appropriately de-identified example and record the task, comment, correction and reason. The school AI pilot checklist can help a faculty decide what to investigate next; these three practice cases are not enough to certify a service.

If you are considering JeddAI for a faculty workflow, get in touch to discuss how teachers will check, edit and release feedback. Use an invented or school-approved example to explain the review you need. Teachers can also create a free teacher account to explore the workflow with a familiar practice task.

Feedback review sheet: copy or print one row per disputed comment. Use permitted examples without identifying students in shared copies.
Check Record your evidence
Comment to inspect Exact wording: ______
Submitted response Relevant sentence, page or working: ______
Subject check Independent calculation or source: ______
Task fit Instruction or criterion that applies: ______
Decision Keep / correct / hold for clarification: ______
Reason and next action What changes, who checks it, and what the student receives: ______

Questions teachers ask

Is feedback trustworthy if it quotes the student accurately?

An accurate quotation is a useful starting point, but the interpretation or requested action may still be wrong. Check what the quoted detail supports and whether the instruction fits the task.

Should every incorrect comment be replaced with a new improvement target?

No. Sometimes the student has already met the relevant criterion. Acknowledge that accurately. Add another target only when you can identify a separate gap in the actual work.

Does asking an AI tool to check itself verify the comment?

It may help surface an alternative explanation, but it does not replace checking the response, calculating independently or consulting the relevant source. Repetition of the same claim is not new evidence.

Do these examples show how often AI feedback is wrong?

No. They are invented exercises illustrating three errors a reviewer can detect. A real evaluation needs appropriate tasks, a defensible reference judgement and records of what was actually observed.

About this guide

Written by Shashank Singhal and reviewed on 9 Oct 2026. Filed under Feedback & Assessment. Looking for study material? Browse Jeddle’s Australian-English study guides.

Keep reading

All teacher guides
Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!