Feedback & Assessment · For teachers

How do you help students separate an event date from a source date?

The short answer

Ask the student to label two things separately: when the event happened and when the source was created. Then have them explain what the gap means for this particular claim. A later recollection can describe an earlier event; its date does not move the event, or automatically make the account worthless.

Four things to remember

  1. Put the event date and the source's creation date on separate lines.
  2. Use the source heading as well as the extract; the date may sit outside the quotation.
  3. Explain what timing allows or limits, rather than labelling every later source unreliable.
  4. Check a new source pair before assuming that a corrected sentence shows understanding.

What is the mistake you need to identify?

A student reads a recollection written in 2024 about a bridge opening in 2004. Their response places the opening in 2024. Writing “check dates” leaves two possible problems unresolved: did the student overlook the heading, or do they think a document must have been written when the event happened? Ask them to point to the date attached to each.

The US National Archives’ document-analysis guidance asks readers to establish when a document comes from, consider the context of its creation and use other evidence to understand the event. Those are separate questions. The lesson below makes that separation visible with an invented example. It is not an official History examination task or marking scheme.

AERO’s formative assessment guidance supports asking learners to explain their thinking and using that evidence to choose the next teaching step. Here, the useful evidence is the student’s reason for assigning each date, not whether they have copied a correction.

Which source cards can you use for a quick demonstration?

Give students the following two cards with their headings intact. Both are fictional materials created for this exercise. Greybank, the people and the documents are invented; the cards are not historical evidence about a real bridge.

Card A — Private diary entry by a Greybank resident, written 18 September 2004: “The footbridge opened this morning. I crossed after the ribbon was cut. From where I stood, people were cheering.”

Card B — The same resident’s recollection, written for a local anniversary booklet in 2024: “At the opening in September 2004, I remember feeling that the bridge would change our town. We had waited years for it.”

Ask students to identify the opening year, the year each account was written and the words or heading that support each answer. For this exercise, the opening is in 2004. Card A was written on the day described; Card B was written twenty years later. The booklet’s 2024 date belongs to the recollection, not the opening.

What feedback makes the distinction usable?

Show this invented response: “The bridge opened in 2024, and the diary proves everyone supported it.” There are two different problems. The opening date has been confused with the booklet date, and a single observer’s description has been turned into a claim about everyone.

Start with a focused prompt: “Write Event: ___ and Card B created: ___. Point to the evidence for each. Now revise the opening date in your sentence.” If the student still puts 2024 in both spaces, model how a person can write today about something that happened earlier. If they label the dates correctly but their sentence is wrong, ask them to revise the wording without re-explaining the whole concept.

Then address the breadth of the claim. A defensible correction is: “The opening took place in 2004. The diary describes cheering near the writer, while the 2024 recollection presents the opening as important to that resident. Neither extract establishes what everyone in the town thought.” This repairs the date and limits the claim to what the invented evidence supports.

For a way to demonstrate one correction while leaving the next attempt to students, use our lesson on modelling revision without giving students the answer. Keep the date correction visible, then ask the class to make the evidence-limit correction themselves.

Does a later source automatically become less useful?

No. Ask what you want to find out. Card A gives an account written on the day, from one person’s position. That timing does not make its observations complete or neutral. Card B tells you how the writer presented the opening in an anniversary booklet twenty years later. It can be useful for studying later remembrance as well as offering an account of the earlier event.

The later date gives you a reason to investigate memory, purpose and other evidence. It does not prove that the writer forgot or invented anything. Likewise, the booklet’s celebratory setting may matter, but a student should not claim that it forced the writer to praise the bridge without evidence.

Keep the question precise: “What can this source support about the opening?” differs from “How was the opening remembered in 2024?” Students can answer these questions differently without placing the event in two different years.

How can you check the idea with a fresh example?

Use this new fictional pair without showing the bridge correction. Card C — Club minutes written on 6 May 1988: “Members voted to open the reading room next month.” Card D — A former member’s recorded interview in 2018: “The reading room opened on 2 June 1988. I was there that afternoon.”

Ask: When was each source created? Which source states that the opening actually happened? What date does it give? Can Card C establish that the plan was carried out? Require a reason beside each answer.

Teacher check: Card C was written in 1988; Card D was recorded in 2018. Card D states that the opening happened on 2 June 1988. Card C records a decision and an intended month, not confirmation that the opening occurred. The interview is an account given thirty years later. To corroborate the opening date, students could seek a dated opening notice, a newspaper report or another relevant record. They should not treat the interview’s date as the opening date.

If a student gives the correct years but says the minutes prove the room opened, the next teaching need is distinguishing a plan from an occurrence. If they use 2018 as the opening year, return to the event/source labels. These errors need different feedback.

What should you do when a source has several dates?

A source can have an event date, an original creation date and a later publication, transcription or upload date. Label the dates that are actually supplied. A diary digitised in 2026 was not necessarily written in 2026; a later edition may also contain new introductions or notes. Check which part of the material the student is using.

If the creation date is unknown, record that uncertainty rather than choosing a year from the event described. A useful sentence might be: “This undated recollection describes the 2004 opening; the supplied information does not establish when it was written.” Return to the catalogue description or source notes to see whether they resolve the question.

How can you reuse the feedback without making it vague?

Copy the planning record below, then replace the example notes with the source and claim in front of you. The feedback comment bank can help you keep a reusable prompt, but the dates and evidence need checking each time. Keep identifiable student material out of shared examples unless your school’s process permits its use.

If your faculty is reviewing History feedback with JeddAI, contact the team about the tasks and source material you use, or book a meeting through the teacher options below. Discuss the feedback you need students to act on; this exercise can serve as one concrete example.

Copy this event-and-source feedback record
Record Worked note for the bridge example
Event and date Bridge opening, September 2004. Both cards refer to this event.
Source creation date Card A: 18 September 2004. Card B: 2024.
Where the dates came from Card headings and the words describing the opening; not the date a worksheet was downloaded.
Claim to repair The opening happened in 2004. One resident's account does not establish everyone's view.
Feedback prompt Label event and source dates separately, explain your evidence, then revise the claim.
Independent check Use the reading-room pair. Check both the date distinction and whether a plan establishes an event.

Questions teachers ask

Should students always calculate the gap between the dates?

Only when it helps the analysis. The important step is distinguishing the dates and explaining what timing means for the question. Naming a twenty-year gap without connecting it to the account is not enough.

Does a later recollection stop being a primary source?

Do not decide from its date alone. Consider the creator's relationship to the event and your research question. A participant's later recollection can provide first-hand testimony about an earlier event and evidence of how that person remembered it later. Check the source's nature and any relevant course definitions.

Can students use the date a source was uploaded online?

Record it as an upload date if that is how it is labelled. Do not substitute it for the original creation date or the event date. Read the record description and distinguish original material from later additions.

Can I use these source cards in an examination?

They are original fictional practice materials, with answers supplied here. Use them to teach and check the distinction. They are not authentic historical sources or an official examination task, and any formal assessment must meet your school's and course's requirements.

About this guide

Written by Shashank Singhal and reviewed on 7 Nov 2026. Filed under Feedback & Assessment. Looking for study material? Browse Jeddle’s Australian-English study guides.

Keep reading

All teacher guides
Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!