What question gets a student past “it’s biased”?
Write this exchange on the board. A student looks at a campaign poster and says, “It’s biased, so we shouldn’t use it.” Ask: “Use it to find out what?” Give the student a moment to name an enquiry. If they cannot, give them two to choose from: what the organisation wanted people to think, or what people actually thought.
Cover the word “biased” in the student’s sentence. What evidence disappears with it? Often there was no evidence in the sentence to begin with. A useful first comment is, “Point to one choice the maker made. Tell me which of our two questions that choice helps you answer.” Leave the label covered until the student has something to say about the source.
This works particularly well with a poster because students can return to exactly the same image while the enquiry changes. The US National Archives poster-analysis worksheet asks readers to identify the maker, audience and visual choices, give evidence for the purpose, then consider what else they would need to investigate. The exercise below puts that last question to work.
What can students establish from the Westinghouse poster?
Open “We Can Do It!” in the US National Archives exhibition Powers of Persuasion. Read the caption as well as the image. The archive credits J. Howard Miller and identifies Westinghouse as the producer for the War Production Co-Ordinating Committee. Ask students to separate what they can see, what the caption tells them and what they infer from the two together.
The woman has one arm bent and her other hand on the turned-up sleeve. Above her, “We Can Do It!” gives the reader a first-person plural pronoun. A student might say the poster presents work as a shared effort. Ask which detail carries the idea of sharing. The pose conveys strength, but the word “we” does more of the work in that particular interpretation.
Now read the claim “Women who saw this poster felt confident at work.” Ask someone to point to the viewer whose reaction the source records. The depicted figure is part of the design. Her expression is evidence of how the artist presented her. It cannot stand in for a record of how a worker responded to seeing the poster. Keep the distinction visible by writing “presents” above the image and “responded” over an empty space beside it.
What feedback would you leave on each answer?
Try these two invented student answers. Ava writes, “Westinghouse is biased because it made the poster.” Joel writes, “The raised arm and the word ‘we’ show that all the workers supported the campaign.” They need different comments. Asking both writers to add a quotation would leave Joel’s main problem untouched.
For Ava, write, “The caption gives you a producer. Which detail in the poster helps you explain what that producer wanted the viewer to see?” A possible revision is, “The poster presents a capable worker and puts ‘we’ in her speech. It gives a historian an example of how Westinghouse framed a message of collective effort.” A student can defend a different reading by pointing to a feature that supports it.
For Joel, underline “all the workers”. Ask, “Whose view do we actually have? What would we need to hear from a worker?” He can keep the image detail and narrow the conclusion. One contemporary worker’s letter describing the poster could support a claim about that person’s reaction if its provenance checks out. One letter would still be a small basis for a claim about everyone.
Can students make the distinction with a different source?
Set aside the wartime poster. Give pairs this fictional town campaign notice, written for the exercise: “KEEP THE FERRY. Tell the council what the morning crossing means to you. Tuesday, 6 pm, town hall. Friends of North Quay.” Give them two questions. What action did the organisers seek? How many people used the morning ferry that week?
For the first question, a student can point to the imperative “Tell the council”, the meeting time and the signature. Together they support a claim that the group wanted people to speak to the council about the service. “Everybody in North Quay depended on the ferry” goes further. The notice calls for accounts of the crossing. It does not supply them, count passengers or report who attended.
For the second question, ask the student to specify the record they would look for. A clerk’s tally for the morning sailings that week could help count journeys. Even a complete tally of boardings would leave open how many different people travelled, because the same passenger might have boarded on several mornings. If a student spots that problem, let them refine the enquiry. That is a better revision than adding a second general sentence about bias.
What should a two-sentence revision do?
Ask one partner to read an answer aloud while the other covers the source. Can the listener tell who made it, which particular choice matters and what the writer is using it to establish? Uncover the source and check the answer against it. With the ferry notice, a listener who hears only “it uses persuasive language” cannot tell whether the group asked people to ride, sign a petition or attend a meeting.
Return the draft with one decision to make. For example: “Keep the meeting details. Change your claim about passenger numbers to one about the action the organisers wanted. Name a different source for the numbers.” Give the student time to make the change. If the new answer still promises too much, ask them to circle the verb that commits them to that promise.
The guide to feedback on evidence offers related examples for choosing a relevant detail. For this exercise, the detail can be accurate and relevant while the inference about the audience still runs too far. Use the copyable record below to preserve both the evidence worth keeping and the limit the student needs to add. Copy the left column for a fresh source and cover the sample answers until the writer has tried the five questions.
How can a faculty compare the feedback it gives?
Ask two teachers to take the same short answer and underline the exact claim they want revised. If one underlines the maker’s name and the other underlines “everyone agreed”, compare what a student would do after each comment. The first might lead to checking the caption. The second calls for rethinking whose opinion the source can establish.
Save a prompt that worked in your feedback comment bank, alongside the enquiry it was used for. “What would show how the audience responded?” is a good prompt when a student has confused message with reception. It adds little to a response that already acknowledges that limit but misidentifies the maker.
If your faculty is exploring JeddAI for teacher-reviewed feedback on History writing, get in touch to discuss how your teachers would check the comments against the actual source. You can book a meeting below or create a teacher account to try your own practice task.
| What the student records | Worked example |
|---|---|
| My enquiry | What did Friends of North Quay want readers to do? |
| Maker and evidence of purpose | The group signed the notice and asked readers to tell the council about the morning crossing. |
| One claim I can support | The organisers wanted residents to speak about the ferry at the meeting. |
| One claim I cannot support yet | The notice alone cannot establish how many passengers used the morning service. |
| What I would look for next | For journeys, check morning boarding counts for the same week. For individual users, the record would also need to distinguish repeat travellers. |



