What must you check before reusing a comment?
A bank entry can sound helpful and still ask a student to do the wrong thing. “Show how your comparison works” is reasonable advice when a response gives only an answer. It is insufficient when the student has already shown a faulty method, and unnecessary when the explanation meets the task. Read the response before choosing the entry.
AERO’s formative assessment explainer connects feedback with evidence of students’ understanding and opportunities to act on the advice. It also describes comment banks organised around task elements. The practice below applies those ideas to an original example; it is not a tested intervention or a claim that a particular wording saves time.
What do these three responses actually show?
Use this invented task: “Which is larger: 2/3 or 3/5? Explain using equal-sized parts of the same whole.” For this exercise, assume the class has already learned to compare equivalent fractions. If that method has not been taught, teach it before asking students to supply it independently. The response labels A, B and C refer to pieces of work, not fixed student ability groups.
Response A: “2/3 is larger.” The comparison is correct, but the response does not show the reasoning requested. Ask how the student decided before assuming they guessed. They may be able to explain a valid method orally and need help recording it; they may also have reached the right answer for a reason that will fail on another pair.
Response B: “3/5 is larger because three is bigger than two.” This student has provided a reason. The problem is that counting numerators alone does not compare differently sized parts of the same whole. Asking for “more explanation” could produce a longer version of the same mistake.
Response C: “2/3 is 10/15 and 3/5 is 9/15, so 2/3 is larger.” This already uses equal-sized parts to support the correct comparison. The shared instruction to show the comparison adds no useful next step here. Check the actual criterion, rather than inventing a weakness so every response receives an improvement comment.
How should the shared comment change?
For A, make the missing action explicit: “Your comparison is correct. Show both fractions in fifteenths or with equal-length bars, then explain which has more equal-sized parts.” If an oral check reveals a misunderstanding, respond to that evidence instead. A prompt to record reasoning cannot replace teaching the reasoning itself.
For B, begin with the unit being compared: “Thirds and fifths are different-sized parts. Draw two equal-length bars and show 2/3 on one and 3/5 on the other. How could we divide both bars into the same-sized parts?” Work through the representation with the student if needed. Dividing each third into five parts and each fifth into three gives 10/15 and 9/15. Ten fifteenths is larger than nine fifteenths.
After that teaching, ask B to replace the original explanation: “I cannot compare these fractions by their numerators alone because ____. Using fifteenths, I can see ____.” A possible completion is that thirds and fifths have different sizes, while 10/15 and 9/15 count the same-sized parts. Check the explanation rather than accepting copied numbers as sufficient evidence.
For C, a short acknowledgement can identify what worked: “You made the parts the same size before comparing them.” If the lesson calls for more practice, use another pair. Do not imply that this completed response needs extra working simply because the bank entry says so. The next task and a correction to the current answer serve different purposes.
How can you tell whether the student can act on it?
Ask the student to explain the next action in their own words, then give time to attempt it. “Do you understand?” can be answered without demonstrating anything. For A, look for the connection between the two equivalent fractions and the comparison. For B, check whether the student can explain why the original numerator comparison was unreliable.
Use a fresh independent check: “Which is larger, 3/4 or 5/8? Explain using equal-sized parts of the same whole.” The teacher check is 3/4 = 6/8, so 3/4 is larger than 5/8. Accept a sound representation or another valid explanation. This one task provides evidence about this comparison; it does not establish mastery of all fraction work.
If the new answer is incorrect, keep the response and the reason together. A calculation slip, unequal whole diagrams and a return to numerator-only comparison call for different follow-up. Do not automatically resend the same paragraph because the first comment was not enough.
What should you save in the shared bank?
Save the conditions for using a comment alongside its wording. A useful record says what evidence must be present, what the teacher needs to replace, when the entry should not be used and how the next attempt will be checked. For this example, “correct comparison, missing explanation” is a narrower and more useful condition than “fractions”.
Keep the original shared wording intact in the bank and adapt a copy for the response in front of you. Replace vague placeholders such as “add detail” with the missing action. Before returning it, ask whether the student has already done that action and whether the instruction assumes knowledge you have not taught.
The feedback comment bank provides a place to select and adapt a starting point. Use the printable practice sheet to discuss the three responses with a colleague before writing your own entries. The tables below repeat the distinctions and provide a record you can copy without using the image.
When the next step needs a demonstration, the guide to modelling a revision without giving away the answer helps you plan the model and a separate student attempt.
If your team wants to explore how JeddAI could support a shared feedback workflow, contact Jeddle with the task, criterion and an anonymised or invented response. Discuss how teachers would check the proposed comments and handle cases where the shared wording does not fit. Teachers can also create an account through the secondary link on this page.
| Response | Decision before sending feedback |
|---|---|
| A: correct comparison, no reason | Ask how the answer was reached; request a recorded comparison using equal-sized parts. |
| B: numerator-only reason | Teach or check the meaning of the parts; then ask for a revised explanation. |
| C: correct equivalent-fraction explanation | Acknowledge the criterion met. Use a fresh task if more practice is needed. |
| Check | Your notes |
|---|---|
| Use when | Evidence that makes this comment appropriate: ____ |
| Response detail | Exact detail I am responding to: ____ |
| Next action | What the student will do, using taught knowledge: ____ |
| Do not use when | Evidence that would make this advice unnecessary or wrong: ____ |
| Check next | Fresh task and what I will look for: ____ |



