Teaching Practice · For teachers

How do you teach students to explain the changes they make?

The short answer

Ask students to show what changed, explain why the change is justified, and try a fresh example. Model the difference between naming an edit and explaining its effect. Read the explanation beside the work: a polished reflection can still hide a wrong idea, while a brief spoken answer may reveal sound reasoning.

Four things to remember

  1. Keep the original and revised work together so the explanation can be checked.
  2. Ask for the reason behind one important change, rather than a long account of every edit.
  3. Use a fresh task to check whether the student can apply the idea without copying the model.
  4. Separate difficulty explaining in writing from difficulty understanding the subject.

What do you want the explanation to reveal?

“I made it better” tells you that a student knows a change was expected. It does not tell you what they understood. A useful explanation connects a particular change to a reason: a mathematical relationship, a detail in a passage, a task requirement or another relevant piece of evidence. That connection gives you something to examine.

AERO’s formative assessment explainer recommends asking students to describe their thinking and using the response to guide feedback and teaching. The examples and reflection sheet here are original ways to put that advice into practice. They are invented classroom material, not records of students, research results or official exemplars.

Choose one important change for the conversation. Keep the earlier attempt visible beside the revision and ask, “What did you change, and what made that change necessary?” Listen for a reason that fits the work. A completed reflection box alone does not establish understanding.

How can a maths example separate an edit from a reason?

Consider an invented response to “Convert 0.4 metres to centimetres.” The original answer is “0.4 m = 4 cm”; the revision is “0.4 m = 40 cm”. Ask the student to explain the change before deciding what it shows. The correct revised number may have come from their own reasoning, your demonstration or a neighbour’s answer.

A description of the edit is: “I added a zero because the teacher said four was wrong.” That accurately reports what happened but gives no account of the units. A reasoned explanation is: “One metre is 100 centimetres. Four tenths of a metre is four lots of 10 cm, which is 40 cm.” It connects the answer to a relationship the teacher can check.

Model that relationship with a metre divided into ten equal parts, each representing 10 cm. Point to four parts. Then ask the student to show where 4 cm would sit on the same length. This gives the numbers a meaning beyond a rule about moving digits.

For a fresh check, ask for 0.07 m in centimetres. One acceptable answer is “7 cm, because a hundredth of a metre is 1 cm, so seven hundredths is 7 cm.” A student who says 70 cm needs further checking of place value and units. A student who answers correctly but cannot yet explain may need a drawing or a follow-up question; do not decide from that single response alone.

What does a reasoned explanation look like in English?

Use this complete invented passage: “Nora told the group, ‘I am not staying.’ She checked the darkening sky, then pushed her torch across the table towards Sam. At the door she paused until he put it in his bag.” The practice question is: “How do Nora’s words and actions present her attitude towards the group?”

An initial response reads: “Nora does not care about anyone because she says she is not staying.” A possible revision is: “Although Nora says she will leave, giving Sam her torch and waiting until he takes it suggest concern for the group’s safety.” The second response accounts for both speech and action, rather than treating one line as the whole picture.

A thin explanation is: “I used a better quote.” A more useful one is: “I changed ‘does not care’ because the torch and her pause suggest concern. My first answer considered only her words, but the revision explains why her actions complicate them.” Ask the student to point to those details. They do not have to use the phrase ‘complicate them’ if they can explain the contrast clearly.

The passage does not establish that Nora will stay, that Sam is helpless or that the group definitely faces danger. Invite students to qualify their claims instead of inventing a backstory. More sophisticated wording would not repair an unsupported interpretation.

How can you check the English reasoning on a fresh passage?

Try this separate invented passage without displaying the model: “‘You can manage without me,’ Arun said. From the gate, he watched until the younger children had crossed the road, then walked in the other direction.” Ask students what his speech and action suggest about his attitude, and which detail supports their answer.

One possible response is: “Arun’s words claim the children do not need him, but waiting until they have crossed suggests he still takes care over their safety.” A useful explanation identifies the contrast between his claim and his watchfulness. Another defensible reading may emphasise giving the children independence while remaining attentive; ask what supports it.

Keep the two judgements separate: did the student make a supported interpretation, and could they explain why? If the interpretation is sound but the explanation is vague, follow up on the specific detail. If both are unsupported, revisit how to connect evidence to a claim. For structuring the response time, use the ten-minute returned-feedback lesson.

How should students use the reflection sheet?

Use the reusable sheet below after one selected revision. Students record the change, its reason, a fresh example and any point that still needs help. They can point, speak or draw before writing where that is appropriate for the lesson. A sentence starter such as “I changed… because…” can help them begin, but it cannot supply the reasoning.

Model an honest uncertainty: “I can show why 0.4 m is 40 cm, but I am not sure how to show 0.07 m.” That tells you more than “I understand now.” Treat the uncertainty as a place to continue teaching. Do not require students to report that feedback helped when they have not understood it.

A short explanation is enough when its reasoning is clear. In the English example, “The torch shows care, so ‘does not care about anyone’ was too strong” does the required work. Asking for a long reflection can turn a useful check into a separate writing task.

For a student’s own revision records across subjects, the exam error log offers a separate place to record a mistake and plan another attempt. The sheet here focuses on explaining one change; it is not a measure of effort or a reflection score.

What should the teacher do with the evidence?

Look for a mismatch between the revision, its explanation and the fresh attempt. A correct revision paired with a mistaken explanation calls for another subject check. A sound explanation paired with a wrong fresh answer needs closer inspection: the issue could be a new misconception, an execution slip or an unfamiliar part of the task. Ask what the student did before choosing the next action.

The guide to giving written feedback students act on covers how to phrase the initial instruction. This follow-up asks whether the student can justify what changed. Avoid treating the fact that a student followed an instruction as proof they can use the idea elsewhere.

If your faculty is exploring JeddAI, get in touch to discuss where student revision and teacher follow-up fit your feedback process. Bring a permitted practice example showing what you want students to explain. Teachers can also use the free-account option below to explore the workflow; checking students’ subsequent understanding remains a teaching decision.

Revision explanation sheet: copy for one change, then inspect the work and fresh attempt together.
Prompt Student record
I changed Original answer or wording: ______ Revised version: ______
My reason The relationship, evidence or requirement that justifies the change: ______
Show it Point to the relevant working, detail or example: ______
A fresh example New attempt and reason: ______
What I still need help with A specific question or uncertainty: ______
Teacher follow-up What to check or teach next: ______

Questions teachers ask

Should students explain every correction?

Select a change whose reasoning matters for the current learning. Explaining every small edit can obscure the point you need to check. Use other corrections when they reveal a separate issue.

Does a correct explanation prove the student has learned it?

It provides useful evidence, but it may reproduce a model or depend on support. Inspect a fresh attempt as well, then check the idea again when it becomes relevant.

What if students struggle to write the reflection?

Let them explain orally, point to the work or use a diagram when appropriate. Check the subject reasoning separately from their ability to compose a written explanation, and provide writing support if that is also a learning goal.

Can students disagree with the feedback?

Yes. Ask them to compare it with the task and evidence. A supported explanation may show that the proposed change is unnecessary or wrong; review the feedback before asking the student to follow it.

About this guide

Written by Shashank Singhal and reviewed on 13 Oct 2026. Filed under Teaching Practice. Looking for study material? Browse Jeddle’s Australian-English study guides.

Keep reading

All teacher guides
Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!