What changes when a student drops a condition?
Put this invented line on the board. Mara tells a harbour committee, “We can open the gate at dawn, after the night crew hands over, if the tide drops.” A student writes, “Mara promises to open the gate at dawn.” Ask the class to choose between two possibilities. If the tide stays high, has Mara broken a promise, or has a condition for opening the gate gone unmet?
Read the full line again before collecting answers. Mara describes what the crew can do under certain conditions. The word “can” stops short of a promise. The last four words make the tide one of those conditions. A reader who has seen only the student’s sentence would have good reason to expect that gate to open whatever happens to the water.
Ask students to mark the smallest piece of the original that would change that reader’s expectation. Many will underline “if the tide drops”. Then ask what else needs changing in the student’s own sentence. Restoring the tide inside quotation marks still leaves “promises” outside them. Both parts belong in the discussion.
Where would you pause the video?
In the accompanying Jeddle Short, pause at about 0:12. On the slide, a short opening fragment is retained and the rest of a longer quotation is crossed out. A note describes breaking longer quotations into parts and using ellipses between them. At about 0:44 the slide shows an example with an omission inside the quotation. Students can see the difference between selecting a fragment and making a cut between two retained fragments.
Give the class a different job with Mara’s line. Instead of finding the shortest version, ask each pair to decide what must survive if the writer wants to discuss uncertainty about the opening. One student chooses the words to keep. The other reads the result as someone who has never seen the source and says what they think Mara has undertaken to do.
The Australian Government Style Manual gives a useful test here. Its guidance on ellipses says that leaving words out must preserve the original intent. Show students how an ellipsis can mark a gap accurately while the surrounding sentence still takes the quotation further than the source allows.
Which shortened version would you accept?
Try this claim first. “Mara sets a condition for opening the gate. The word ‘if’ makes the proposal depend on the tide.” The single quoted word is enough for this explanation when the surrounding sentence tells readers what the condition applies to. A student who quotes a single word is still responsible for what the whole sentence claims.
Now consider a longer answer. “Mara says, ‘We can open the gate at dawn … if the tide drops.’ The crew has an opportunity at dawn, but the water level might rule it out.” The omitted words concern the handover. The quotation preserves both the possibility and the tide condition. This cut is defensible for the stated claim, which concerns the water.
Change the question to “How does the passage present the handover between crews?” That same shortened quotation now removes the very detail the answer needs. Restore “after the night crew hands over” or quote that phrase on its own and explain who depends on whom. A cut can preserve the speaker’s intention and still leave a student with poor evidence for a particular question.
What feedback gives the writer a decision to make?
Try writing this beside the original student response. “Underline the word that makes the opening conditional. If the water stays high, can you still defend ‘promises’? Try another reporting verb and read your sentence again.” Give the writer the original line when you give the comment. Without it, the task turns into guessing which verb the teacher wants.
Compare two replies. “I changed promises to says” removes an overstatement, but gives no account of the missing condition. “I wrote that Mara sees a possible dawn opening, because ‘if the tide drops’ leaves the outcome unsettled” repairs the claim and explains the choice. A different verb can work if the student can defend the whole sentence.
The guide to feedback on evidence has examples for students who have picked the wrong detail altogether. Here, the words about dawn really are in the passage. The problem is what the writer asks that detail to prove.
Can students find a different kind of misleading cut?
Use a fresh example before handing out the checking record. In this invented committee minute, Leila says, “I used to think the crossing was too far from the school. Walking the route with the families changed my mind.” A student writes, “Leila objects to the crossing because it is ‘too far from the school’.” Ask partners to identify the claim, locate the exact quoted words and say whether Leila would recognise that account of her position now.
The quoted words are exact. The student has turned an earlier view into a present objection. One repair is, “Leila recalls that she ‘used to think’ the crossing was too far away. Walking the route changed her view.” Another is to quote the second sentence in full and paraphrase the former view. Neither answer needs to claim that Leila now considers the crossing ideal. The passage gives the change of mind without specifying her new judgement in that much detail.
Offer one last version: “Leila now supports the crossing.” Ask whether the minute gives enough evidence for that sentence. A student might reasonably infer that Leila no longer holds her old objection, yet still hesitate over “supports”. Ask what further words Leila would need to say before the writer could make the stronger claim.
What can the class keep for the next draft?
Copy the five questions in the checking record into the margin of the next essay draft. Have each writer test one shortened quotation and tell a partner which detail they kept, restored or paraphrased. One defensible decision gives you something specific to discuss when you collect the work.
Keep a prompt such as “Would the speaker recognise this as their view at this point?” in your feedback comment bank. Try it against the actual line before pasting it into a comment. In Mara’s case the question is about a condition. In Leila’s it is about time.
If your faculty is looking at how teachers could review JeddAI feedback on English analysis, get in touch to discuss the examples your students find difficult. You can also book a meeting below or create a teacher account to try a practice task.
| Ask the writer | Mara’s example |
|---|---|
| What does my sentence claim? | That Mara promises a dawn opening. |
| Which words am I relying on? | “open the gate at dawn” |
| What did I leave out that matters? | “can” and “if the tide drops” limit certainty. |
| What would an unfamiliar reader infer? | That the gate will open even if the water stays high. |
| What will I change, and why? | Describe a possible opening and restore the tide condition. Keep the handover detail if the question concerns the crews. |



