Which mistaken idea do you want to check?
Write the idea as a sentence a student might believe. ‘They do not understand fractions’ is too broad to guide a question. ‘When adding fractions, add the denominators as well as the numerators’ gives you something specific to investigate. Use an error you have seen in work, or a plausible error you want to check; do not assume every student shares it.
Keep the question focused on that idea. If unfamiliar vocabulary or a complicated calculation gets in the way, you may be testing something else. Solve it yourself, consider alternative interpretations and check that the expected response follows from what students have been taught. One small question should inform your next teaching move, not label a student’s general ability.
What does a worked question look like?
Here is an original classroom example. Ask: ‘What is 1/3 + 1/3? Choose A: 2/6, B: 2/3, or C: 1/6. Explain what the 3 represents.’ The correct answer is B. We have one third and another third of the same whole, making two thirds. We are counting parts of an unchanged size; we have not divided the whole into six equal parts.
Option A creates a chance to investigate the add-both-numbers error. It does not prove that a student used that rule: they could have guessed, misread the question or copied another response. Option C is also wrong, but its meaning is less specific. Ask how the student reached it instead of supplying a story about their thinking. The explanation is part of the evidence.
A correct choice needs interpretation too. ‘I added the top numbers and kept the bottom number’ describes a procedure. ‘They are thirds of the same whole, so one third plus one third is two thirds’ explains why the denominator stays the same. You can ask a student who gives only the procedure to show the quantities with equal parts of a strip.
How should students respond?
Give students a brief individual thinking period, then collect an answer and a reason on paper or mini whiteboards. Ask everyone to show their responses together so you can inspect the range of thinking before opening discussion. AERO’s formative-assessment guidance includes scanning students’ written responses and asking them to explain their thinking as ways to check understanding.
Make the language accessible without doing the reasoning for them. Read the prompt aloud if that is an appropriate support, explain a word that is incidental to the concept, or let a student demonstrate with a drawing. If the task is checking fraction addition, difficulty writing a sentence should not be the only route through which understanding can be shown.
What will you do with the different explanations?
Prepare a response to the thinking, not only to the letter chosen. If a student explains A by adding both top and bottom numbers, use one whole divided into three equal parts and combine two of those parts. Ask what changed: the number of thirds selected, or the size of a third? Then return to the written fraction. Keep the same whole throughout the demonstration.
If students choose B but cannot explain it, ask for a model or explanation before deciding that the concept is secure. If their reasoning is sound, move to a fresh application. If responses are mixed, a short discussion or small-group explanation may be more useful than repeating the same instruction to everyone. There is no universal percentage threshold that makes this decision for you.
Record a short next step in the feedback comment bank if you want to reuse it: ‘Show both quantities as thirds of the same whole, then explain why the sum is still measured in thirds.’ Check the fit each time. A shared comment is only useful when it addresses the thinking in that particular response.
How can you check the teaching response worked?
After the explanation, ask a fresh question: ‘What is 2/5 + 1/5? Explain your answer using fifths of the same whole.’ The answer is 3/5. This changes the numbers while retaining the idea being checked. Ask for the reason again; repeating the answer to the first question would not tell you whether students can apply the explanation elsewhere.
Keep the conclusion modest. A correct explanation now is useful evidence for the next lesson step, not proof of permanent understanding. Revisit the idea later in another context. If the same error appears, inspect whether the model, wording or prerequisite knowledge needs attention. The point of gathering the response is to change what you teach next.
For a reusable planning sheet, copy the table below and fill every row before the lesson. Our guide to turning vague feedback into a revision task can help you turn the observed gap into an action students can complete.
If you want to discuss how JeddAI could fit into a teacher-reviewed feedback process, get in touch with the task and the evidence you want to check.
| Planning prompt | Worked example | Your question |
|---|---|---|
| Mistaken idea to investigate | Add denominators when adding like fractions | ______ |
| Question and choices | 1/3 + 1/3: A 2/6, B 2/3, C 1/6 | ______ |
| Reason to ask for | What does the 3 represent? | ______ |
| Correct explanation | Two thirds of the same whole; parts stay the same size | ______ |
| Teaching response | Combine two thirds on one equal-part strip | ______ |
| Fresh check and answer | 2/5 + 1/5 = 3/5; explain in fifths | ______ |



